Is Judge Walker’s Opinion On Same Sex Marriage Really that Great?

This supporter of same sex marriage is not very impressed. I agree. Though I oppose sex sex marriage I was looking forward to seeing a better legal argument.

I think this is apt:
"I don’t think his opinion rests on particularly solid legal ground, let alone a proper interpretation of the constitution’s text. It may well be perfect pitch to Justice Kennedy, but predicting the inclinations of one idiosyncratic justice is not a particularly good measure of a legal argument’s intrinsic force. So while some fiind Judge Walker’s opinion powerful and convincing, I remain unconvinced".