Should Catholics Shut Up In Questoning Obama - A Response

On the whole more GOP leaning Republicans did not demand that lets say more liberal Catholics shut up on the criticism of Bush. Whatever criticism was meant by earnest debate.

Now it seems on many blogs and elsewhere some criticism by the more Conservative leaning Catholics is meant with Catholic blog anathemas.

A sad State of affairs.

Father Z responds to this at The Problem With Toning Down the Rhetoric – And Why We Probably Won’t Do It (Note there is a huge in his text just keep scrolling down)

If you disagree what does he get wrong?