Monday, February 23, 2009

Catholic Priest Talks About Real Life Problems with RCIA

Fr. Philip Neri Powell, OP a convert from the Mississippi Delta writes in part at his post Benedict, Monkeys, RCIA...


What to do if my parish's RCIA program is not very Catholic?

I've posted before about my own RCIA experience in 1995-6. Not good. The process as it is laid out in the relevant documents promises to be something of an adventure in learning to become a good Catholic. In the hands of a faithful pastor and a dedicated RCIA team, the process is wonderful.

Unfortunately, too often the process leads converts into a world of pseudo-Catholicism, or worse, anti-Catholicism. The central difficult, I think, is that the pedagogy of the process places too much emphasis on "sharing the faith" and almost none of learning the faith.

How can a group of people who know little or nothing about the Catholic faith share that faith with others who know as little as they do? This is not to say that they have nothing to share! Of course, they do. But RCIA is meant to be an introduction to the CATHOLIC faith not a year-long process of sharing feelings, impressions, and opinions about bullet-point theology and ecclesial politics.

Many converts are left with the impression that the Catholic faith is simply a matter of joining a parish, signing up for duty as communion ministers, and occasionally going to Mass on Sunday. When the emphasis is placed on the subjective experience of the individual, the whole of the faith is lost in personal reflection and opinion.

The strongest/weakest link in any RCIA program is the dedication of the teachers to the magisterium of the Church. Often these teachers are reluctant to present the more controversial elements of the faith for fear of being confronted by disagreement or disparagem.

Tough. Teach the faith or find another ministry in the parish. I know a young RCIA convert who was shocked to discover when he came to U.D. that the Church teaches that Christians who struggle with same-sex attractions are called to celibate chastity. As one such Christian, he was told that the Church honors one's conscience on this issue and says nothing at all about the sinfulness of sexual behavior for homosexuals!

In other words, he joined the Church believing that he could, as a homosexual, find a partner and live, in good conscience, a sexually active lifestyle. To his credit, he accepted the Church's teaching once he knew the truth. However, he signed up believing a lie told by his RCIA team. Why did they tell him this? Maybe they believed they were telling him the truth. Maybe they didn't want to risk controversy. Maybe they don't accept the Church's teaching on this issue. and use the RCIA program to teach error in the hope of undermining the teaching. Who knows? Whatever the reason, this young man was lied to and those who did the lying shouldn't be teaching the faith!. (Check out the link for more)


So true. The frustrating thin is that every Catholic Parishes should be getting tons of converts a year. The problem is the quality of RCIA programs are so hit and miss. I was very fortunate to have a great RCIA program at College when I poped. However not 3 years later when my best Friend converted there was a new priest a new team and the experience was horrid. I mean horrid beyond belief.

This is a area I really think the Diocese needs to take a lot more oversight into as to training and other matters.

My advice to Orthodox Catholics is you know someone that is thinking about becoming Catholic to really inquire around town which RCIA programs are good and push them there. Plus take an active role in helping them out.

3 comments:

Carlos Echevarria said...

did you get my Kmiec email?

James H said...

I have not checked my email yet. I am going there next

Subvet said...

My wife was one of apparently many who emailed Fr. Phillip about RCIA. Our problem here is that it either spends too much time Protestant bashing, which isn't a good way to win over an audience consisting mostly of Protestants, or a lot of touchy-feely type of verbosity thats long on form and short on actual substance.

Since I've been selected to be her sponsor, I often find myself enduring these classes with her. Offering it up for the suffering in Purgatory is gonna insure the place empties real soon!

Easter can't come soon enough.