Did The Bush Administration Actually Follow Catholic Teaching on Torture?

Part II of this discussion. See A Response to The Catholic Blogs Magisterum On Torture (updated)

As I mentioned the discussion appearing in the comment section involving all parties is pretty good for a change on this issue. I note Jonathan Prejean of Crimson Catholic has chimed in. (I know he is from Louisiana but I forget if he is Crimson because he is at Harvard or much worse Bama :(

Anyway he is bucking conventional wisdom that perhaps looking at the Bush White House view of enhanced interrogation in the most charitable light that it lines up with Catholic teaching.

I am sure that will bring some interesting responses.

Update I- Mark Shea at Inside Catholic is having none of this and has given a reposnse to some issue raised. See Tonight We're Gonna Party Like It's 1984