Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Douthat on Angels and Demons in The New York Times

A very good op-ed in the NYT today.

I think this part is very apt

Brown’s message has been called anti-Catholic, but that’s only part of the story. True, his depiction of the Roman Church’s past constitutes a greatest hits of anti-Catholicism, with slurs invented by 19th-century Protestants jostling for space alongside libels fabricated by 20th-century Wiccans. (If he targeted Judaism or Islam this way, one suspects that no publisher would touch him.)

But Brown doesn’t have the soul of a true-believing Enemy of the Faith. Deep down, he has a fondness for the ordinary, well-meaning sort of Catholic, his libels against their ancestors notwithstanding. He’s even sympathetic to the religious yearnings of his Catholic villains — including, yes, the murderous albino monks.

This explains why both “The Da Vinci Code” and “Angels and Demons” end with a big anti-Catholic reveal (Jesus had kids with Mary Magdalene! That terrorist plot against the Vatican was actually launched by an archconservative priest!) followed by a big cover-up. A small elect (Tom Hanks and company, in the movies) gets to know what really happened, but the mass of believers remain in the dark, lest their spiritual questing be derailed by disillusionment and scandal. Having dismissed Catholicism’s truth claims and demonized its most sincere defenders, Brown pats believers on the head and bids them go on fingering their rosary beads.

In the Brownian worldview, all religions — even Roman Catholicism — have the potential to be wonderful, so long as we can get over the idea that any one of them might be particularly true. It’s a message perfectly tailored for 21st-century America, where the most important religious trend is neither swelling unbelief nor rising fundamentalism, but the emergence of a generalized “religiousness” detached from the claims of any specific faith tradition.

The polls that show more Americans abandoning organized religion don’t suggest a dramatic uptick in atheism: They reveal the growth of do-it-yourself spirituality, with traditional religion’s dogmas and moral requirements shorn away. The same trend is at work within organized faiths as well, where both liberal and conservative believers often encounter a God who’s too busy validating their particular version of the American Dream to raise a peep about, say, how much money they’re making or how many times they’ve been married.

46 comments:

  1. The funniest bit from Douchehat's column:

    It isn’t just that he knows how to keep the pages turning. That’s what it takes to sell a million novels. But if you want to sell a 100 million, you need to preach as well as entertain — to present a fiction that can be read as fact, and that promises to unlock the secrets of history, the universe and God along the way.It's too bad Douchehat himself doesn't realize why this is funny.

    ReplyDelete
  2. buy valium no prescription buy cheap valium uk online - top pharmacy valium

    ReplyDelete
  3. generic viagra where to buy viagra online us - safest place order viagra

    ReplyDelete
  4. generic viagra order viagra with paypal - best place buy viagra online yahoo

    ReplyDelete
  5. viagra online without prescription purchase viagra singapore - www cheap viagra com

    ReplyDelete
  6. cheap viagra online buy viagra us over counter - order viagra professional

    ReplyDelete
  7. generic viagra does viagra work on paraplegics - generic viagra brand

    ReplyDelete
  8. soma drug soma san diego 21 - soma 500mg side effects

    ReplyDelete
  9. soma generic soma san diego 2010 - soma drug test information

    ReplyDelete
  10. buy soma online soma without prescriptions cod - soma muscle

    ReplyDelete
  11. buy soma soma san diego rules - side effects soma pills

    ReplyDelete
  12. soma 350 mg order soma watson online - soma radio

    ReplyDelete
  13. buy soma online can you buy soma online - soma buy online no prescription

    ReplyDelete
  14. buy somas online buy soma usa - soma pills 446

    ReplyDelete
  15. buy soma online soma vanishing back bra - soma sushi

    ReplyDelete
  16. cheap cialis cialis reviews by women - buy cialis ebay

    ReplyDelete
  17. order tramadol online cod buy tramadol rx online - where to buy tramadol over the counter

    ReplyDelete
  18. buy cialis online order viagra cialis online - cheap cialis nz

    ReplyDelete
  19. tramadol online no prescription buy tramadol online in florida - tramadol hcl what is it for

    ReplyDelete
  20. buy tramadol online can overdose tramadol - overdose of tramadol for dogs

    ReplyDelete
  21. xanax 1mg generic xanax buy online - how to buy xanax online

    ReplyDelete
  22. generic xanax xanax withdrawal valerian - xanax anxiety forum

    ReplyDelete
  23. generic xanax xanax 2mg used - xanax bars urine test

    ReplyDelete
  24. generic xanax xanax mixed with alcohol - xanax green bars s 90 3

    ReplyDelete
  25. buy tramadol cod overnight buy tramadol with paypal - 3 50 mg tramadol

    ReplyDelete
  26. cialis buy online no prescription cialis price shoppers drug mart - buy cialis holland

    ReplyDelete
  27. online xanax how much xanax and alcohol can kill you - alprazolam 0 5mg medley

    ReplyDelete
  28. generic xanax xanax withdrawal 1mg per day - xanax xr 1mg high

    ReplyDelete
  29. cialis online cheap cialis daily - generic cialis yahoo answers

    ReplyDelete
  30. buy cialis online how to buy cheap cialis - buy cialis in us

    ReplyDelete
  31. can you buy cialis online how to order cialis online - cheap 2.5 mg cialis

    ReplyDelete
  32. buy cialis online generic cialis vs brand name cialis - cheap cialis tablets

    ReplyDelete
  33. legal buy tramadol online order tramadol no prescription overnight - tramadol for dogs dosage usa

    ReplyDelete
  34. http://landvoicelearning.com/#57594 tramadol 50 mg for ultram - boompanjang blogspot buy tramadol online

    ReplyDelete
  35. learn how to buy tramdadol buy tramadol online without rx - tramadol 100mg sr tablet

    ReplyDelete
  36. buy tramadol online tramadol hcl 37.5 - buy tramadol cod free

    ReplyDelete
  37. klonopin anxiety klonopin and alcohol recreationally - klonopin reviews

    ReplyDelete
  38. http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#6817 klonopin mg get high - klonopin withdrawal numbness

    ReplyDelete
  39. klonopin pill ways get high klonopin - klonopin withdrawal depersonalization

    ReplyDelete
  40. buy klonopin online klonopin overdose - klonopin 834

    ReplyDelete
  41. order tramadol online mastercard tramadol legal to order online - can tramadol withdrawal kill you

    ReplyDelete
  42. http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#cheap side effects of reducing klonopin - rivotril klonopin 2mg

    ReplyDelete
  43. discount klonopin klonopin kidney damage - klonopin side effects vision

    ReplyDelete
  44. carisoprodol soma carisoprodol 350 mg withdrawal - buy carisoprodol cod

    ReplyDelete
  45. carisoprodol 350 mg there drug test carisoprodol - carisoprodol d 31

    ReplyDelete