To say the least. See Bp. Finn (D. KC, MO) on Notre Dame, Obama’s speech
I like this part
Q:] Without identifying any person or group, Notre Dame President Father John Jenkins in his introduction of the President warned against a tendency to “demonize each other”. Were the bishops who spoke in opposition to an honorary doctorate of law for President Obama “demonizing” him or Notre Dame?
I think the bishops (and many others) were pointing out the hurtful nature of the invitation. As I reread Fr. Jenkins’ remarks I found it fell into three parts. In the first part Fr. Jenkins himself uses a whole series of very, very hard words. He uses the words – division, pride, contempt, demonize, anger, distort, hateful, condemn, hostility. And one might wonder whether he uses these words as a kind of a caricature of the 60 to 70 bishops who have spoken out against his invitation.The center part is all about dialogue. He uses the word dialogue, I think, six times.
And he quotes it from Pope Benedict, and he quotes it from Ex Corde Ecclesiae and he quotes from the Second Vatican Council.And in the third part, he expresses his admiration for the President. So this seems to be the way he sets up the President’s talk for him – to speak in a very negative way about anyone who appears to be contrary to the decision they made, and then to stress the primacy of dialogue, and then offer his admiration of the President. Dialogue is important, but the question is fairly raised, “May we negotiate about things that are intrinsic evils?” and I think the answer is no.
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
Bishop Jenkins of Kansas City- St Joseph Not Pleased With Father Jenkins of Notre Dame
Posted by James H at 5/19/2009 12:36:00 PM
Labels: Catholic, Catholic Politics, catholic social justice, notre dame, obama, United State Catholics
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment